Beautiful decorated sugar cookie cutouts topped with sweet, light, and colorful frosting! Each cookie is carefully hand-decorated with smooth, creamy frosting in cheerful pastel colors that are as delightful to look at as they are to eat. Our classic sugar cookies feature a soft, chewy center and are transformed into edible works of art perfect for celebrations, gifts, or treating yourself. Our seasonal designs rotate throughout the year—spring brings pastel florals and Easter themes, summer features bright patriotic and beach-inspired designs, fall showcases pumpkins and harvest motifs, and winter celebrates festive holiday classics. Available in a variety of fun shapes and designs—each one a sweet little masterpiece from our bakery!

Celebrate life's sweetest moments with our Laser Printed Frosted Sugar Cookies. Each cookie features a smooth butter cream frosting base, topped with custom designs created using food-safe laser printing and edible ink. Perfect for graduations, weddings, anniversaries, and special occasions, these personalized treats add an elegant touch to any event. Our laser-printed designs are crisp, detailed, and completely edible—no artificial decorations. Whether you're marking a milestone or adding a custom detail to your celebration, these cookies deliver both beauty and taste. Handcrafted with premium ingredients and finished with precision, they're as delicious as they are stunning. Have a design in mind? Send us a picture and we'll work with you to bring your vision to life on every cookie.

Brighten your day with our classic Lemon Bars! These irresistible treats feature a buttery shortbread crust topped with a smooth, tangy lemon filling that's perfectly balanced between sweet and tart. Each bar is baked to golden perfection and dusted with a light coating of powdered sugar for an elegant finish.

Bright and buttery lemon danish with a delicate pastry shell and tangy lemon filling. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of sweet and citrus, with a light glaze that catches the morning light. Freshly baked daily at Pep's Bake Shop, this grab-and-go treat pairs beautifully with coffee or tea. Perfect for breakfast, brunch, or a midday pick-me-up.

Long John donuts are rectangular, yeast-raised pastries fried until golden and filled with your choice of smooth cream or rich custard. Our cream-filled Long Johns are topped with chocolate buttercream icing and a satisfying coconut crunch, while our custard-filled varieties feature classic chocolate buttercream icing. Perfect for breakfast, dessert, or whenever you crave an indulgent treat.

Warm, gooey, and irresistible – our chocolate chip cookies are everything a cookie should be. We start with a time-tested recipe using real butter, brown sugar, and pure vanilla, then fold in generous amounts of premium semi-sweet chocolate chips.

Each batch is baked fresh to order, ensuring you get that just-out-of-the-oven experience. The result? A perfectly balanced cookie with crispy golden edges and a soft, tender center that melts in your mouth.

Swing by the bakery store front to grab a cookie today or order by the dozen or half dozen for your next gathering, gift, or personal treat!

Artisan marble rye bread with a beautiful swirl of light and dark rye, creating a striking visual and complex flavor profile. This hearty loaf combines the nutty depth of rye with a tender crumb and subtle sweetness. Perfect for sandwiches, toast, or enjoying fresh with butter. Handcrafted using premium ingredients for authentic European-style baking. Each 1.5# loaf delivers rustic charm and satisfying substance to your table.

Mary's Famous Sandwich Loaf

Layers of homemade goodness in every slice!

Our signature Sandwich Loaf is handcrafted with alternating layers of our from-scratch white and wheat bread, generously filled with egg salad, tuna salad, Cheese Whiz, ham salad, and chicken salad. Each layer is held together with a rich, creamy cream cheese spread, creating the perfect balance of flavor in every bite.

Perfect for lunch, family gatherings, parties, picnics, or whenever you're craving something hearty and satisfying.

✔ Pre-scored for easy serving
✔ Averages 8–9 slices per loaf
✔ Simply slice, serve, and enjoy!

Flavorful Tradition, Ready to impress, Only at Pep's Bake Shop!

Mary's Famous Sandwich Loaf

Layers of homemade goodness in every slice!

Our signature Sandwich Loaf is handcrafted with alternating layers of our from-scratch white and wheat bread, generously filled with egg salad, tuna salad, Cheese Whiz, ham salad, and chicken salad. Each layer is held together with a rich, creamy cream cheese spread, creating the perfect balance of flavor in every bite.

Perfect for lunch, family gatherings, parties, picnics, or whenever you're craving something hearty and satisfying.

✔ Pre-scored for easy serving
✔ Averages 16–18 slices per loaf
✔ Simply slice, serve, and enjoy!

Flavorful Tradition, Ready to impress, Only at Pep's Bake Shop!

Layers of savory goodness in every slice. Our Sandwich Loaf features tuna salad, egg salad, ham salad, and chicken salad stacked with a cheese layer in the center, all wrapped in a smooth coating of rich cream cheese. Perfect for lunch, gatherings, or when you want something hearty and satisfying. Slice and serve.

Mint M&M Cookies make an excellent holiday treat.  Crafted with the classic M&M cookie dough, these cookies incorporate not only M&M’s but also Andes chocolate mints, resulting in a delightful mint flavor. Perfect for the holiday season.

Indulge in our oversized muffins, baked fresh to order. Our signature offering features rich pistachio flavor, but we're happy to create custom flavors for your special requests. Perfect for breakfast, brunch, or a satisfying treat. Place your order and let us know your preferred flavor—we'll bake it just for you.